FANDOM

An anonymous contributor
  Loading editor
  • Hey, so myself and some other users went through and were trying to verify some ages, it seems a couple are missing verification and since you were around on the wiki during the era when a lot of these were decided I was wondering if you could help?

    Jet: Jet's age is cited as SDCC 2007, on his talk page you said that was what you thought the source was but in the thread people said it was missing from the video and transcript, did you ever get a clearer source on that?

    Suki: On her page you say the source is the nick.com avatar index, but I checked the tumblr archive and the archive.org text archive but I couldn't find it.

    Also, if there is any chance you know the sources for the ages of Meng, Haru, and the fact that Aang got Appa at age 6, that would be appreciated as well, but it's okay if you don't. Thank you!

      Loading editor
    • For Jet, I don't recall pursuing the info beyond that. For Suki, if I said it then, it was probably there. I'd often check the site for info. There was a time I went ahead and basically created articles on everything the site had that we didn't have articles on. If it's not in the archive, either the text was changed before the archive was made (the original site did get neglected and buggy before Nick abandoned it), or the image was listed in a non-text way, maybe an image? Some of the info we have from there are descriptions of stuff in images. I've always been a stickler for sources, so I don't think I would have said that if there wasn't a solid source. No idea for the other other stuff, but it was probably the Nick site as well, that was basically the only source of information we had back then other than the episodes themselves.

        Loading editor
    • Ah, I see. Hm, I thought that the text archive would have everything and I hadn't realized they'd been changing things. I wish there was a way to get back the archive of what it was before crashing because at the moment it looks like the only archives are of around the same time.

        Loading editor
    • An anonymous contributor
        Loading editor
  • Hey there! I noticed you've undone my edits to File:Monks.png on multiple occasions, and was hoping to explain my reasoning, then let you decide.

    Firstly, I believe we can both agree that at least two monks in that image are council members: Tashi and the unnamed, long-bearded one. Logic-wise, the other two monks resemble two other members on the council not accounted for, and subtracting Gyatso, it would explain why there are only four, no more, no less.

    The image is taken from afar, so we can hardly make out any of the faces or facial hair on the faces from that distance, so claiming Pasang is not present while Tashi is just from the image is a little hypocritical. "Tashi" could just as well be some other white-bearded monk by your logic.

    Besides this, why would the writers of the series have any need to have the fruit pies thrown at anyone besides the council members. If anything, Gyatso did it for Aang to make him feel better about his responsibilities.

    Now that I have provided a solid argument, I'm hoping you can see from my point of view. Thanks for reading!

      Loading editor
    • I have undone it to the last revision prior to the issue, because in such a circumstance, the status quo prevails. If it is decided that the monk is Pasang, then we can edit it to indicate thusly.

        Loading editor
    • Going to jump in here and say that I agree with Omni that the monk in the image is not Pasang. Yes the image is from afar, but the third monk very clearly has facial hair different to that of Pasang. On this basis, I would propose editing Pasang's article to remove that piece of trivia and switch any reference to the foursome as the council of elders to just monks. This removes any speculation on our part.

        Loading editor
    • Yes, you can see the facial hair. The guy in that image has a thick, bushy mustache. Compare that to other images where Pasang's face is visible, like the one in his infobox. Pasang's mustache is very thin, completely different. Tashi's facial on the other hand, is consistent in all images. The trivia in Pasang's should be removed, and mentions of Pasang in other articles relating to that scene should also be removed.

        Loading editor
    • An anonymous contributor
        Loading editor
  • Why do you undo my changes

    Amon was the strongest bloodbender in the series is the wrong?

      Loading editor
    • An anonymous contributor
        Loading editor
  • If you know everything about avatar then who’s stronger Amon or katara and give me reason

      Loading editor
    • An anonymous contributor
        Loading editor
  • Why do you undo my changes ?

      Loading editor
  • I think this is the thread you were looking for.

    And this page has the sentence we are looking for.

      Loading editor
    • An anonymous contributor
        Loading editor
  • It's a high resolution screenshot from the DVD series, cropped within the guidelines of the image policy. In what bloody way is it not the kind of image used here?

      Loading editor
    • The whole gigantic file thing is not what is done in this wiki. Look at every image from either series, in their file pages. Every single one of them is a small file, with the dimensions that are usually used in articles themselves. Even in images that used to have huge files, they've since been updated for smaller files.

        Loading editor
    • Also, just as a general note: a bigger file doesn't mean that it is higher resolution. The current file is just a resized file of a HD screenshot of the series. As such, the current file is already high resolution. It's only the size that differs, but there is simply put no reason to host such large images on this wiki when smaller sized work just as well and don't take as long to load.

        Loading editor
    • An anonymous contributor
        Loading editor
  • Why did you undo my post on lightning generation? I thought it related well to the page, considering that many pages also contain bits of trivia relating science to the world of Avatar. 

      Loading editor
    • The nature of fire and lightning in-universe is already attributed to being energy. The portions on how emotional state relate to how the energy is utilised is at best speculative or just plain wrong, since the only aspects of emotion shown to be truly necessary for firebending are drive and self-control, and both those concepts are compatible with the mind state required for lightning generation.

        Loading editor
    • An anonymous contributor
        Loading editor
  • Hi,

    I was wondering: could you please restore the pages for Major characters and Minor characters in Smoke and Shadow?

    Lady Lostris gave her reason as 'unused category'. 

    So, if you would please restore them, I shall fill in those categories. I find them highly necessary and vital pages. 

    Thank you,

    Justice 

      Loading editor
    • An anonymous contributor
        Loading editor
  • Sorry; I will re-edit it. My theory was that Ozai mentioned in "The Search" about worrying Zuko was a non-bender and was going to be cast away.

      Loading editor
    • An anonymous contributor
        Loading editor
See archived talk page
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message